Wide Scope A philosophy blog that ranges over philosophy and other fun stuff.

Archive for February, 2010

Young Philosophers Updated Schedule: Spring 2010

02.15.2010 · Posted in Young Philosophers

I now have rooms and times officially booked for our remaining three Young Philosophers visits. Here is all of the information regarding our three remaining speaker visits. Dennis Whitcomb Western Washington University (Ph.D., 2007, Rutgers University) “Grounding Precludes Omniscience” (Research Talk) February 25, 6PM Fenton 105 “Two Branches of Wisdom” (Intro Talk) February 26 @ 12PM Fenton 105 Todd Long California Polytechnic State University (Ph.D., 2003, ...

Three Arguments That Belief is Conceptually Prior to Knowledge

02.11.2010 · Posted in epistemology

Part of Williamson’s case against the possibility of analyzing knowledge involves rejecting three candidate arguments for the thesis that belief is conceptually prior to knowledge. These all come up in the introduction of Knowledge and Its Limits.1 Here is my best attempt to extract these arguments. The labels are my own. The Argument from Non-reflexive Entailment Knowledge ...

Watch Young Philosophers on Your TV!

02.11.2010 · Posted in Young Philosophers

Young Philosophers was just approved to distribute to the Roku Player on the Blip.TV channel. So if you have a Roku Player, you can watch Young Philosophers on your big TV from the comfort of your couch. I don’t see any way to browse to the show. The easiest way to find it ...

More on Posting to Wordpress from Google Docs

02.09.2010 · Posted in Uncategorized

A few weeks ago, I discovered that you can post to Wordpress from Google Docs. But if you follow those instructions, titles won’t import into Wordpress. However, I just found However, if you follow this set of instructions - titles from Google Docs will import into Wordpress. Now I have a useful tool on my ...

Weatherson on Gettier

02.09.2010 · Posted in Uncategorized

Aren’t there analyses of knowledge that do less violence to our intuitions than JTB, but also have about as good a claim to analyze knowledge in terms of a natural property as JTB (e.g. JTB that isn’t based on false grounds)? If that’s right, then it seems that Weatherson’s defense of JTB in “What Good Are ...

Williamson’s Caring Argument Against Analyzing Knowledge

02.08.2010 · Posted in epistemology, philosophy

Williamson thinks that the fact that we have yet to come up with a suitable analysis of knowledge post-Gettier, among other things, should push us to accept that there is no analysis of knowledge. He thinks that we should treat knowledge as an unanalyzable primitive. Here’s something I find puzzling, he argues that we should regard knowledge ...