Category Archives: justification without awareness

Justification Without Awareness - Chapter 3 and 4

Chapters 3 and 4 are sort of slow-going. The good stuff really comes in at chapter 5. I’m going to quickly lay out brief summaries of chapters 3 and 4. But I’ll warn you now - this will be quick and I won’t have anything substantive to say in this post in the way of [...]

Justification Without Awareness - Chapter Two

In the previous post on Justification Without Awareness - I laid out Bergmann’s dilemma for the internalist. The next two chapters explore ways to avoid the dilemma. In this chapter, Bergmann critically discusses two philosophers’ views that grab the weak awareness horn and two philosophers’ views that grab the strong awareness horn.
Richard Fumerton
Bergmann says that [...]

Justification Without Awareness - Chapter One

I’m teaching special topics course in epistemology this year. We’re going through Michael Bergmann’s new book Justification Without Awareness. I thought it would be fun to post quick summaries of the chapters here, and critically discuss them along the way. Here’s a quick summary of chapter one.
Chapter One
In this chapter, Bergmann develops and defends a [...]